Customer Experience · 21 November 2026
Loyalty Investment Rises, But 32% Say Rewards Exceed Expectations
New arrivia research finds 90% of consumers expect to stay loyal to their preferred brand, yet only 32% say its rewards programme consistently exceeds their expectations.
What happened
Most consumers say they plan to stay loyal to the brands and organisations they already prefer, but far fewer believe those brands' rewards programmes are delivering. New research from arrivia finds that 90% of consumers expect to remain loyal to their preferred brand or organisation, yet only 32% say its rewards programme consistently exceeds their expectations.
CustomerThink reported the findings under the headline that loyalty investment is rising, while U.S. consumers want more from their rewards programmes. The framing points to continued spending on loyalty alongside a clear gap between stated intent to stay and satisfaction with the rewards on offer.
Why it matters
For experience leaders, the gap between intent and satisfaction is the core signal. A 90% expectation of loyalty paired with 32% reporting that rewards consistently exceed expectations suggests that loyalty is being sustained by something other than the rewards mechanic alone. It also suggests that when rewards fall short of what customers anticipate, the programme can become a source of disappointment rather than reinforcement.
The finding also bears on where investment goes. If budgets are rising while satisfaction with rewards lags, the more useful question for CX and loyalty teams may be whether rewards are visible, relevant and easy to redeem, rather than how many new features can be added.
By the numbers
- 90% of consumers expect to remain loyal to their preferred brand or organisation, according to new arrivia research.
- 32% say that same brand or organisation's rewards programme consistently exceeds their expectations.
The Renascence take
Loyalty conversations often treat stated intent as the prize. This research suggests intent is the easier part to earn, and that the rewards programme is being asked to justify a choice customers have already leaned towards.
The real gap is not between loyal and disloyal customers; it is between a promise and a moment. Rewards that fail to exceed expectations usually fail in the redemption journey, the timing of recognition or the relevance of the offer, not in the size of the points balance. A customer-obsessed operator should map the last few interactions a member has with their rewards and fix the most frustrating point of friction before funding another campaign.
Sources
This briefing was written by our Newsdesk, synthesising reporting from the outlets below. Follow the links for the original coverage.
FAQ
Questions we get on this topic
More in Customer Experience
Stay ahead of CX
Get the signal, not the noise.
The stories shaping customer experience — plus the Journal and Experience Loom — in your inbox.


