Behavioral Economics
8
 minute read

Disjunctive Fallacy: Overestimating the Probability of Disjunctions

Published on
August 28, 2024

1. Introduction to Disjunctive Fallacy

Imagine a customer considering multiple potential benefits of a new product but failing to realize that not all of these benefits are likely to occur together. This scenario highlights the Disjunctive Fallacy, where individuals overestimate the probability of multiple outcomes happening together. In Customer Experience (CX), understanding this fallacy is essential for setting realistic expectations and preventing dissatisfaction due to unmet assumptions.

2. Understanding Disjunctive Fallacy

Disjunctive Fallacy occurs when people assume that the probability of several events happening together is higher than the probability of each event occurring individually. Psychologically, this fallacy arises from a misunderstanding of probabilities and the tendency to focus on potential positive outcomes without considering their likelihood. In everyday decisions, this fallacy can lead customers to overestimate the benefits of a product or service, resulting in disappointment if those benefits are not fully realized.

  • Impact on Customer Behavior: Customers influenced by the disjunctive fallacy may set unrealistic expectations for products or services, leading to dissatisfaction if their assumptions are not met.
  • Impact on CX: In Customer Experience (CX), the disjunctive fallacy can lead to misaligned expectations and increased complaints, as customers may feel misled or disappointed by the actual performance of a product or service.
  • Impact on Marketing: Marketing strategies that fail to manage expectations effectively may exacerbate the disjunctive fallacy, leading to dissatisfaction and reduced customer loyalty.

3. How to Identify Disjunctive Fallacy

Identifying Disjunctive Fallacy in customer interactions and marketing involves several strategies:

  • Expectation Management Audits: Conduct audits of marketing materials and customer communications to ensure that expectations are realistic and not overstated, reducing the risk of the disjunctive fallacy.
  • Customer Feedback on Expectations: Collect feedback to understand customer expectations and identify any discrepancies between perceived and actual outcomes, indicating the presence of the disjunctive fallacy.
  • Behavioral Analysis of Customer Decision-Making: Monitor customer decision-making processes to identify patterns of overestimating the probability of multiple outcomes, suggesting a disjunctive fallacy.
  • Surveys on Outcome Expectations: Conduct surveys to assess customer expectations regarding products or services, identifying potential misunderstandings or overestimations of benefits.
  • A/B Testing for Expectation Setting: Test different marketing messages to determine which approaches set realistic expectations and reduce the impact of the disjunctive fallacy.

4. The Impact of Disjunctive Fallacy on the Customer Journey

Disjunctive Fallacy can affect multiple stages of the customer journey, particularly where expectations and outcomes play a significant role:

  • Research: During the research stage, the disjunctive fallacy can lead customers to overestimate the benefits of a product or service, resulting in unrealistic expectations.
  • Exploration: In the exploration phase, assumptions based on the disjunctive fallacy can result in disappointment if customers discover that not all expected benefits are likely to occur together.
  • Selection: At the selection stage, the disjunctive fallacy can influence product or service choices based on unrealistic expectations of multiple benefits occurring simultaneously.
  • Purchase: During the purchase phase, the disjunctive fallacy can affect satisfaction if customers realize that their expectations were unrealistic or overstated.
  • Onboarding/First Use: The disjunctive fallacy can impact the onboarding experience if customers expect multiple benefits to be realized immediately, potentially leading to dissatisfaction or confusion.
  • Loyalty: Failing to manage expectations due to the disjunctive fallacy can reduce loyalty, as customers may feel misled or disappointed by unmet assumptions.
  • Advocacy: Customers influenced by the disjunctive fallacy may advocate for products or services based on unrealistic expectations, potentially leading to negative word-of-mouth if those expectations are not met.

5. Challenges Disjunctive Fallacy Can Help Overcome

Understanding and addressing Disjunctive Fallacy allows businesses to tackle several challenges:

  • Improving Expectation Management: By recognizing and mitigating the disjunctive fallacy, businesses can set more realistic expectations and reduce dissatisfaction due to unmet assumptions.
  • Enhancing Customer Satisfaction: Effective expectation management helps ensure that customers have a realistic understanding of what to expect, enhancing satisfaction and loyalty.
  • Reducing Complaints and Returns: Addressing the disjunctive fallacy can reduce complaints and returns by aligning expectations with actual outcomes, improving overall satisfaction.
  • Building Trust and Credibility: Mitigating the disjunctive fallacy helps build trust and credibility by ensuring that customers receive accurate and realistic information about products and services.

Relevant Challenges:

  • Expectation Management, Satisfaction, Complaints, Returns, Trust, Credibility, and Loyalty are areas where understanding and addressing the disjunctive fallacy can enhance the customer experience by setting realistic expectations and preventing dissatisfaction.

6. Other Biases That Disjunctive Fallacy Can Work With or Help Overcome

Enhancing Biases:

  • Optimism Bias: The disjunctive fallacy can enhance optimism bias, where customers overestimate the likelihood of positive outcomes and benefits.
  • Confirmation Bias: Customers influenced by the disjunctive fallacy may seek out information that confirms their optimistic assumptions, reinforcing unrealistic expectations.
  • Anchoring Bias: Initial expectations about multiple benefits can anchor decision-making processes, reinforcing the disjunctive fallacy.

Overcoming Biases:

  • Negativity Bias: By setting realistic expectations, businesses can help overcome negativity bias, where customers focus disproportionately on negative outcomes or missed expectations.
  • Recency Bias: Effective expectation management can reduce the impact of recency bias, where recent negative experiences overshadow overall satisfaction.
  • Availability Heuristic: Providing clear and realistic information can mitigate the availability heuristic, where decisions are influenced by recent or memorable information.

7. Industry-Specific Applications of Disjunctive Fallacy

  • E-commerce: Online retailers can reduce the disjunctive fallacy by providing clear, detailed product descriptions and managing customer expectations about the benefits of different products.
  • Healthcare: Hospitals can address the disjunctive fallacy by providing realistic information about treatment outcomes and potential benefits, reducing unrealistic expectations.
  • Financial Services: Banks can mitigate the disjunctive fallacy by clearly communicating the risks and benefits of financial products, helping customers set realistic expectations.
  • Technology: Tech companies can reduce the disjunctive fallacy by providing accurate information about product features and capabilities, ensuring customers have realistic expectations.
  • Hospitality: Hotels can address the disjunctive fallacy by providing clear information about amenities and services, reducing unrealistic expectations and enhancing satisfaction.
  • Education: Educational institutions can reduce the disjunctive fallacy by providing realistic information about program outcomes and benefits, helping students set realistic expectations.
  • Telecommunications: Telecom companies can mitigate the disjunctive fallacy by clearly communicating service features and limitations, helping customers set realistic expectations.
  • Real Estate: Real estate agents can reduce the disjunctive fallacy by providing clear information about property features and potential benefits, ensuring clients have realistic expectations.
  • Automotive: Car dealerships can address the disjunctive fallacy by providing accurate information about vehicle features and performance, helping customers set realistic expectations.
  • Retail: Retail stores can mitigate the disjunctive fallacy by providing clear product information and managing customer expectations about the benefits of different products.
  • Pharmaceuticals: Pharmaceutical companies can reduce the disjunctive fallacy by providing realistic information about drug benefits and side effects, helping patients set realistic expectations.
  • Utilities: Utility companies can address the disjunctive fallacy by providing clear information about service options and potential benefits, reducing unrealistic expectations.

8. Case Studies and Examples

  • E-commerce Example: Warby Parker
    Warby Parker reduces the disjunctive fallacy by providing clear, detailed product information and managing customer expectations about the benefits of their eyewear, enhancing satisfaction and trust.
  • Healthcare Example: Cleveland Clinic
    Cleveland Clinic addresses the disjunctive fallacy by providing realistic information about treatment outcomes and potential benefits, reducing unrealistic expectations and enhancing patient satisfaction.
  • Financial Services Example: Vanguard
    Vanguard mitigates the disjunctive fallacy by clearly communicating the risks and benefits of financial products, helping customers set realistic expectations and enhancing satisfaction.
  • Technology Example: Apple
    Apple reduces the disjunctive fallacy by providing accurate information about product features and capabilities, ensuring customers have realistic expectations and enhancing satisfaction.

9. So What?

Understanding Disjunctive Fallacy is crucial for businesses aiming to enhance Customer Experience (CX). By recognizing and addressing this fallacy, companies can set more realistic expectations, improve satisfaction, and reduce complaints and returns. Mitigating the disjunctive fallacy helps ensure that customers have a realistic understanding of what to expect, building trust and credibility. Integrating strategies to reduce the disjunctive fallacy into your CX approach can differentiate your brand and build stronger relationships with your customers. Learn more about how to address the disjunctive fallacy in your customer experience strategy with our Customer Experience services and explore the benefits of Behavioral Economics in CX for enhancing satisfaction and reducing dissatisfaction.

Share this post
Behavioral Economics
Aslan Patov
Founder & CEO
Renascence

Check Renascence's Signature Services

Unparalleled Services

Behavioral Economics

Discover the power of Behavioral Economics in driving customer behavior.

Unparalleled Services

Mystery Shopping

Uncover hidden insights with our mystery shopping & touchpoint audit services.

Unparalleled Services

Experience Design

Crafting seamless journeys, blending creativity & practicality for exceptional experiences.

Get the Latest Updates Here

Stay informed with our regular newsletter and related blog posts.

By subscribing, you agree to our Terms and Conditions.
Thank you! Your subscription has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong. Please try again.
Renascence Podcasts

Experience Loom

Discover the latest insights from industry leaders in our management consulting and customer experience podcasts.

No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
Latest Articles in Experience Journal

Experience Journal's Latest

Stay up to date with our informative blog posts.

Marketing
5 min read

How to Boost Your Marketing Strategy

Learn effective strategies to improve your marketing efforts.
Read more
View All
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Behavioral Economics
2
min read

The Chronicle Journal: Behavioral Science Is Set To Revolutionize Customer Experience

REBEL Reveal is engineered to bridge the gap between Behavioral Economics and Customer Experience, providing businesses with actionable insights to enhance their CX strategies. The toolkit features 36 meticulously designed cards, each focusing on a specific behavioral bias and its effect on key CX areas such as customer satisfaction, loyalty, engagement and more.
Read more
Customer Experience
2
min read

Benzinga: Behavioral Science Is Set To Revolutionize Customer Experience

Designed for CX professionals, managers, and business leaders, REBEL Reveal offers flexibility and customization to suit various organizational needs. The deck’s user-friendly format allows teams to easily incorporate behavioral insights into their CX strategies, fostering a deeper understanding of customer behaviors and preferences.
Read more
Behavioral Economics
2
min read

FOX40: Behavioral Science Is Set To Revolutionize Customer Experience

Designed for CX professionals, managers, and business leaders, REBEL Reveal offers flexibility and customization to suit various organizational needs. The deck’s user-friendly format allows teams to easily incorporate behavioral insights into their CX strategies, fostering a deeper understanding of customer behaviors and preferences.
Read more
Service Design
12
min read

Service Design in 2025: Emerging Trends Shaping Customer-Centered Experiences

Service design is evolving rapidly, driven by technological advancements, changing customer expectations, and a focus on sustainability.
Read more
Service Design
12
min read

Service Design in Restaurants: Crafting Exceptional Dining Experiences

Service design in the restaurant industry focuses on creating a seamless, enjoyable experience for diners, from the moment they make a reservation to their final interaction with the staff.
Read more
Service Design
12
min read

Service Design in Hotels: Crafting Memorable and Seamless Guest Experiences

Service design in the hotel industry focuses on creating guest-centered experiences that are seamless, enjoyable, and memorable.
Read more
Service Design
12
min read

Top Service Design Books: Essential Reads for Enhancing Customer Experiences

Service design is a field that combines creativity, strategy, and empathy to improve how services are delivered and experienced.
Read more
Service Design
12
min read

Service Design for Dummies: A Simple Guide to Crafting Great Customer Experiences

Service design is about creating and organizing services to meet customer needs and make their experiences smooth, efficient, and enjoyable.
Read more
Employee Experience
12
min read

Employee Experience (EX) for Gen Z: Key Strategies to Engage the Next Generation of Talent

Generation Z (born between 1997 and 2012) is reshaping the workplace with distinct expectations and values.
Read more
Employee Experience
12
min read

Employee Experience Gifts: Thoughtful Ideas to Boost Engagement and Morale

Employee Experience (EX) gifts play a meaningful role in building a positive workplace culture, enhancing engagement, and showing appreciation for employees’ contributions.
Read more
Employee Experience
12
min read

Employee Experience (EX) Guide: Building a Positive and Productive Workplace

Creating a positive Employee Experience (EX) is essential for fostering engagement, satisfaction, and productivity within an organization. A well-structured EX strategy supports employees at every stage of their journey, from onboarding to growth and development.
Read more
Employee Experience
12
min read

Employee Experience (EX) and Artificial Intelligence (AI): Transforming the Workplace

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is increasingly transforming the employee experience (EX) by automating tasks, personalizing interactions, and enhancing overall engagement.
Read more
Employee Experience
12
min read

What is Employee Experience (EX)? A Definition

Employee Experience (EX) refers to the collective journey employees have with an organization, encompassing every interaction, milestone, and touchpoint from recruitment to departure.
Read more
Employee Experience
12
min read

Employee Experience (EX) Jobs: Roles, Skills, and Impact on Organizations

Employee experience (EX) roles have become increasingly vital as organizations recognize the importance of fostering a positive work environment to enhance engagement, productivity, and retention.
Read more
Employee Experience
12
min read

Employee Experience (EX) in 2025: Trends Shaping the Modern Workplace

In 2025, the landscape of Employee Experience (EX) has evolved significantly, influenced by shifts in work environments, employee expectations, and organizational priorities.
Read more
Employee Experience
12
min read

Enhancing Employee Experience with Innovative Tools

In today's competitive business landscape, organizations recognize that a positive employee experience (EX) is crucial for attracting and retaining top talent.
Read more
Employee Experience
12
min read

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for Employee Experience (EX): Measuring Engagement, Satisfaction, and Productivity

Employee Experience (EX) KPIs are metrics that help organizations track and improve the quality of the work environment, employee satisfaction, and engagement levels.
Read more
Employee Experience
12
min read

The Employee Experience Cycle: Key Stages to Foster Engagement and Satisfaction

The Employee Experience (EX) cycle refers to the journey employees take within an organization, from the initial recruitment phase to their eventual exit.
Read more